Subaru Crosstrek-Premium vs Toyota Tacoma

Searchshop currently shows 2 listings for the Subaru Crosstrek-Premium from 1 dealer alongside 2,021 listings for the Toyota Tacoma from 42 dealers, with prices and dealer locations updated continuously. On price, the Subaru Crosstrek-Premium runs roughly 47% below the Toyota Tacoma at the median ($23,163 vs $43,808), which adds up across the typical loan term. Listings span model years 2019–2024 for the Subaru Crosstrek-Premium and 2004–2026 for the Toyota Tacoma, so there's flexibility on both sides whether you're cross-shopping new, late-model, or used.

A live-data comparison like Subaru Crosstrek-Premium vs Toyota Tacoma gives cars and trucks buyers a more realistic picture than spec sheets alone — the prices shown here reflect actual dealer asking prices, not MSRP. When evaluating cars and trucks at this price point, experienced buyers typically weigh service history, mileage, trim level, and remaining powertrain warranty alongside the headline number. The Subaru Crosstrek-Premium currently carries the lower median asking price, which compounds meaningfully over a 48-to-72-month financing term — even a modest gap per month adds up to hundreds of dollars by payoff. Broader selection from the Toyota Tacoma side gives buyers more negotiating room and reduces the chance of settling on a unit that's slightly off on color, trim, or mileage. Running a VIN history report and scheduling an independent pre-purchase inspection are the two most effective steps for catching hidden accident history, odometer rollbacks, or deferred maintenance before signing. Insurance premiums, fuel costs, and scheduled maintenance intervals vary between models and trim levels — comparing total five-year cost of ownership, not just sticker price, often changes the calculus significantly. Listings refresh continuously as dealers update their feeds — check back if a specific cars or trucks you're tracking changes in price or status.