Searchshop currently shows 2 listings for the Arctic Cat Alterra-450-Limited from 2 dealers alongside 10 listings for the Polaris Phoenix-200 from 6 dealers, with prices and dealer locations updated continuously. On price, the Polaris Phoenix-200 runs roughly 33% below the Arctic Cat Alterra-450-Limited at the median ($4,999 vs $7,499), which adds up across the typical loan term. Listings span model years 2026–2026 for the Arctic Cat Alterra-450-Limited and 2024–2026 for the Polaris Phoenix-200, so there's flexibility on both sides whether you're cross-shopping new, late-model, or used.
A live-data comparison like Arctic Cat Alterra-450-Limited vs Polaris Phoenix-200 gives ATVs and side-by-sides buyers a more realistic picture than spec sheets alone — the prices shown here reflect actual dealer asking prices, not MSRP. When evaluating ATVs and side-by-sides at this price point, experienced buyers typically weigh hours of operation, tire and suspension wear, and aftermarket accessory packages alongside the headline number. The Polaris Phoenix-200 currently carries the lower median asking price. Financing terms are not calculated here, so compare actual lender offers separately. The Polaris Phoenix-200 currently has the broader active selection, giving shoppers more listings to inspect side by side. Ask for service records and inspect the skid plates, A-arms, and CV boots; this page does not infer wear from the model name. Trailer requirements, protective gear, and riding-area fees are not included in the listing-price comparison. Listings refresh continuously as dealers update their feeds — check back if a specific ATVs or side-by-sides you're tracking changes in price or status.
No single answer fits every buyer. Use the live inventory signals below to match the right atv to your priorities.
Dealer-description facts come from individual listings. AI-assisted summaries are generated from stored listing evidence. Recall and owner context is model-year level, not listing-specific.
AI summary coverage: 0 of 2 active listings.
No structured description facts are stored for the sampled listings.
No AI-assisted listing summary is stored for the sampled listings.
No stored model-year context is available for the sampled listings.
AI summary coverage: 0 of 10 active listings.
No structured description facts are stored for the sampled listings.
No AI-assisted listing summary is stored for the sampled listings.
No stored model-year context is available for the sampled listings.
Looking for inventory in your state…
The Polaris Phoenix-200 has a lower median asking price ($4,999) than the Arctic Cat Alterra-450-Limited ($7,499) across current Searchshop listings.
Polaris Phoenix-200 has more selection — 10 active listings versus 2 for the Arctic Cat Alterra-450-Limited.
Listings for the Arctic Cat Alterra-450-Limited on Searchshop currently range from $7,499 to $7,499 with a median of $7,499, across 2 dealers.
Listings for the Polaris Phoenix-200 on Searchshop currently range from $4,299 to $4,999 with a median of $4,999, across 6 dealers.
